Best Mai Tais in Maui: Sip Your Way to Tropical Bliss Now!

Welcome fellow Mai Tai lovers!

You know, one of my fondest memories was when my boyfriend and I first tried a delightful Mai Tai on our romantic getaway to Maui. Little did we know that this island paradise had so much more to offer than just its breathtaking beaches and landscapes! So, buckle up as I take you on a journey through some incredible bars in Maui serving the most amazing Mai Tais we’ve ever tasted.

Having explored what feels like every nook and cranny of this beautiful island for the perfect tropical beverage, let me tell you – I’m quite the connoisseur now. These aren’t your run-of-the-mill touristy spots; these are true hidden gems blessed with top-notch bartenders who have spent years crafting their signature cocktails.

Now here’s a secret: Though each of these places boasts impressive menus filled with irresistible concoctions, they all share one thing in common – an unparalleled mastery over the iconic Mai Tai. Trust me; it’s impossible not to get hooked!

Warning: Don’t blame me if after visiting these superb establishments, you find yourself daydreaming about those heavenly sips while reminiscing about your delightful experiences at Maui’s finest! (Seriously though, grab a designated driver or book an Uber – safety first!)

Alright folks, enough talking – it’s time for us to dive into those phenomenal flavors together! Let’s embark on our delectable quest for the best Mai Tais in Maui that will leave you savoring every last drop!

Monkeypod Kitchen – Home to Maui’s Best Fruit-Flavored Mai Tai

When you think of a fruity drink, you might imagine something akin to fruit punch. However, Monkeypod Kitchen serves up a unique and outstanding Mai Tai that defies expectations.

The standout feature of their signature Mai Tai is the lilikoi (passionfruit) foam topping, adding a delightful hint of fruitiness. This irresistible concoction has become so popular among customers that Monkeypod Kitchen reportedly sold around 115,000 Mai Tais in one year alone!

Besides the enticing lilikoi foam, other ingredients in this acclaimed drink include honey, egg whites, lilikoi puree, and simple syrup.

While Monkeypod Kitchen also offers an impressive lineup of delicious food options, it is undoubtedly the Mai Tais that steal the spotlight. A visit to this vibrant spot (reservations are highly recommended) will have you convinced – and be prepared for an unforgettable experience!

What makes Monkeypod Kitchen stand out:

  • Unique fruit-flavored twist on classic Mai Tai with lilikoi foam
  • Delectable food pairing options enhancing your overall dining pleasure
  • Welcoming atmosphere drawing guests from near and far
  • Strong emphasis on using locally sourced ingredients

Duke’s Beach House – Unforgettable Mai Tais with an Exotic Tropical Fruit-Rum Blend

At Duke’s Beach House, the delectable Mai Tais stand out due to their unique combination of fresh pineapple, passion fruit, orange, and guava juice (PPOG). Mixed with a blend of light and dark rum, this drink brings a captivating splash of tropical pizazz.

In addition to its memorable Mai Tai’s, Duke’s is also famous for its fantastic happy-hour menu. Here guests can enjoy 50% off prices on selected items while indulging in these unrivaled drinks.

Why Duke’s Beach House should be on your must-visit list:

  • Signature Mai Tai crafted with a tantalizing PPOG juice and rum mix
  • Remarkable happy-hour deals that bring visitors back for more
  • Idyllic ambiance ideal for relaxing or catching up with friends

Three’s Bar and Grill – The Go-To Spot for Budget-Friendly, Delicious Mai Tais

Defying the misconception that budget-friendly options can’t deliver great taste, Three’s Bar and Grill in Maui proves you can have both. Offering some of the island’s best Mai Tais with prices starting as low as $3.50, this place caters to patrons seeking affordable indulgence.

For a little extra extravagance, their top-tier Mai Tai at $6.50 includes an added touch of Puerto Rican rum. And if the value wasn’t enticing enough already, happy hour (3-6 pm) features “half-off” deals you won’t want to miss.

In summary, Three’s Bar and Grill is an exciting destination where you can relish a delightful array of drinks and snacks surrounded by a lovely outdoor dining atmosphere.

Highlights of visiting Three’s Bar and Grill:

  • Affordable yet exceptional Mai Tai selection
  • Irresistible happy-hour deals from 3-6 pm
  • Comfortable outdoor dining setup perfect for relaxation

Mama’s Fish House – Renowned for Signature Non-Alcoholic Mai Tais and More

Mama’s Fish House is celebrated for its delightful signature Mai Tais, especially the non-alcoholic variety that appeals to both children and adults. Prepared using a sugar syrup base, it offers a refreshing alternative to the classic tart alcohol-based version.

However, savory Mai Tais are not the only reason to visit Mama’s Fish House. The restaurant also prepares an unforgettable dessert called Polynesian Black Pearl—lilikoi-flavored chocolate mousse nestled within a delicate pastry shell that is sure to delight your taste buds.

Don’t forget their affordable happy hour menu featuring an array of mouthwatering appetizers perfect for relaxing afternoons or pre-dinner gatherings. Keep in mind that booking a reservation is highly recommended since this popular spot often fills up quickly.

A visit to Mama’s Fish House promises:

  • Innovative non-alcoholic and classic alcoholic Mai Tai options
  • An irresistible dessert lineup including the unique Polynesian Black Pearl
  • A budget-friendly happy hour with delicious food choices
  • A convivial atmosphere best enjoyed by making reservations in advance

Kimo’s – Home to Classic Hawaiian Style Mai Tais and Exquisite Dining

Kimo’s reputation for serving exceptional classic Hawaiian cuisine is well-established, so it’s no wonder that their Mai Tai adheres to the original recipe while showcasing unbeatable freshness. Patrons often express feeling as though the ingredients were just picked from nearby trees.

In addition to its delectable drinks, Kimo’s offers breathtaking views of Maui’s natural beauty from a relaxing patio area—perfect for soaking in stunning landscapes while sipping your beverage.

Aside from the iconic Mai Tais, Kimo’s is renowned for its mouthwatering desserts, particularly the Hula Pie. This scrumptious treat consists of macadamia nut ice cream layered over a cookie crumb crust drenched in chocolate fudge and topped with whipped cream. It’s my go-to indulgence whenever I’m visiting Maui!

For an unforgettable experience featuring delicious drinks and desserts in a beautiful setting, there’s no better destination than Kimo’s.

Key reasons to visit Kimo’s:

  • Enjoy traditional Hawaiian-style Mai Tais made with fresh ingredients
  • Savor striking views of Maui from a comfortable patio seating area
  • Indulge in decadent desserts like the renowned Hula Pie

Fleetwood’s on Front Street – Unparalleled Upscale Mai Tais and Stylish Ambience

Owned by legendary rocker Mick Fleetwood, Fleetwood’s on Front Street is a popular haunt among the likes of Steven Tyler and other rock stars. This unique restaurant delivers top-notch service with an impressively cool vibe, highlighted by live music performances and sunset ceremonies.

Fleetwood’s serves up an exceptional Mai Tai, known as the “Mai Tyler,” crafted from fresh pineapple, lime juice, two types of rum, and enhanced by inventive almond and ginger flavors for an irresistibly smooth kick.

The gourmet food options are equally memorable and delicious. However, be aware that prices at this upscale establishment can be relatively high. But many would argue that savoring drinks in the company of rock royalty makes it worth every penny.

Why a visit to Fleetwood’s should be on your list:

  • Sip on extraordinary upscale Mai Tais with creative flavor twists
  • Experience iconic live music events in a lively atmosphere
  • Rub shoulders with rock star patrons while enjoying sumptuous fare


Maui has plenty of options for choosing a fun-filled way to spend your nights. And no other better way to end your day than by downing the classic Mai Tai. 

I hope my article might have helped you sift through the numerous options to enjoy this drink. 

My list has something for everyone to enjoy, whether you like your drinks strong and fruity or prefer to enjoy them in an upscale or budget-friendly setting. You will find something to suit your tastes.

Last Updated on May 15, 2023 by Brigitte