Best Desserts in Maui

Welcome to the delectable world of Maui’s desserts! I’ve had my share of eating in this sweet paradise over the past six years. To be precise, you’re about to get insights from someone who’s sampled every dessert that was ever whipped up on this island – thank god for my fast metabolism and my boyfriend’s insatiable sweet tooth!

Here’s a bite-sized reality: If sugar were a currency, we’d probably own an island in Hawaii by now! But our decadent adventures have been worth it, as they’ve led us to discover Maui’s very best dessert places – all three of them.

These spots stand out among a sea of others – they serve confections that surprise your palate while reminding you of home comfort. We broke our diets countless times to bring you these precious gems because sharing is caring!

Warning: Brace yourself for sugar spikes – but fear not! Our cover story today can withstand anyone’s blood glucose levels or current dietary restrictions!

Coming up next are yet more mouthwatering descriptions and recommendations from someone who has thoroughly ‘researched’ every corner bakery on this idyllic island. Now take off your calorie-counting glasses… let’s plunge into Maui sweetness overload!

Ululani’s Hawaiian Shave Ice – Best Place for Authentic Local Sweets in Maui

Among the vibrant marketplaces and stunning beaches of Maui, there lies a sweet secret that visitors to this beautiful island simply cannot miss: Ululani’s Hawaiian Shave Ice. Nestled within the bustling heart of Lahaina, this renowned dessert spot is your ticket to experience a taste of authentic Hawaiian cuisine.

On one particularly warm summer day during our exploration of Lahaina, my boyfriend and I were on the hunt for something to satiate our sweet tooth and cool us down. A kind local steered us towards Ululani’s —a bit off from where we were staying—but with an enthusiastic recommendation like his, we owed it to ourselves (and you!) not to pass it up!

Even though greeted by quite a long queue upon arriving at the shop, we knew it was worth waiting for when locals too lined up in droves. The anticipation built as we approached closer to the counter; finally, ordering Tiger’s Blood shave ice drenched in strawberry, watermelon, and coconut syrup made every second worthwhile. As the refreshing combination tingled on our tongues under the sultry sun, any remnants of fatigue washed away instantly.

Here are some reasons why Ululani’s proved itself as Lahaina’s premier dessert stop:

• Plenty of Parking: With an expansive parking area fronting their shop directly.
• Scenic Views: Showcasing murals sprinkled with elements true-to-Hawaiian culture along with breathtaking ocean views enhance your treat-eating experience.
• Ample Seating Space: Dotted around covered tables shielded from direct sunlight letting you enjoy your chilled shave ice comfortably.
• Varied Menu: Offering anything from succulent strawberries or tangy blueberries through rich chocolates right alongside exotic guava – ensuring no palate remains unimpressed!
• Affordable Prices: Bowls range between $5-$15 depending chiefly on size and chosen toppings.

Operating hours: 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM (Saturday – Friday)
Address: 790 Front St, Lahaina, HI 96761, United States

Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop – Best Sweet Retreat in Maui

Don’t let your taste buds miss out on a unique culinary experience at Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop, your sweet sanctuary located in the heart of Lahaina. Famous for dishing up lip-smacking homemade traditional pies, this charming joint has something to satiate every sweet tooth.

During our shopping spree in Maui, my boyfriend and I stumbled upon Leoda’s. Immediately welcomed by its homely ambiance and friendly staff, we found ourselves drawn into trying their delightful desserts. The toughest part? Picking our poison from the delectable spread!

I succumbed to the sinful chocolate pie while my boyfriend went for an eclectic mix of strawberry and apple crumb pie. Each bite was an explosion of flavour – crispy crust enveloping fresh, soft fillings had us ordering more slices for later! Trust me; you’ll be doing yourself a disservice if you don’t try these pies. They are just too good to pass up!

Here’s what made Leoda’s Kitchen & Pie Shop an unforgettable experience:

• Private Parking: In bustling Lahaina, finding parking can be quite a challenge but not at Leoda’s. Their spacious lot ensures hassle-free parking.
• Outdoor Seating: You have the option to enjoy your dessert amid stunning views thanks to their covered outdoor seating area.
• Extensive Menu: Apart from divine pies (their star attraction!), they also serve sandwiches, breads, burgers, salads opening up a world of mouth-watering options!
• Prices: The cherry on top? Their surprisingly affordable prices will make you want to sample everything without breaking your budget!

Operating hours: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM (Everyday)
Address: 820 Olowalu Village Rd., Lahaina HI 96761

Sugar Beach Bake Shop – A Must-Visit Dessert Haven in Maui

Unearth a local secret on your Hawaiian adventure, the Sugar Beach Bake Shop. Nestled within the heart of Kihei’s Shops of Wailea, this charming corner offers irresistible traditional Hawaiin desserts you don’t want to miss!

On a tip from our locally based friends, my boyfriend and I chanced upon this cozy confectionery during a heavy shopping spree. We loaded up on their specialties, indulging ourselves as we replenished our energy.

Sampling Hawaiian Malasadas was a highlight. They were perfectly crisp with filled ones delightfully fresh – gooey chocolate tantalizing our taste buds (chocoholic alert!). Strawberry-topped malasadas tempted us next alongside delectable peach and apple options.

Our order wasn’t complete without some heavenly hot chocolate coupled with tender pastries that burst with flavor at every bite.

We cherished these enticing features at Sugar Beach Bake Shop:

1. Scenic Beauty: It surely is “eye-candy”! Enjoy panoramic views of verdant landscapes set against oceanic blue hues while you soothe your sweet tooth.
2. Menu Diversity: Get ready for an extensive spread comprising malasadas, croissants, donuts, pies- you name it! Opt for take-out to keep savoring later.
3. Budget-Friendly: The prices are easy on the pocket; expect to shell out between $1-$5 per dessert.
4. Pet Welcoming: Bring along your fur buddies – they’re welcome if leashed!

Their adorable packaging ensures freshness by sealing each treat individually before being handed over to eager patrons like me and my partner.

Operating hours: Monday – Thursday: 6 am – 2 pm | Friday & Saturday: 6 am – 4 pm
Address: 61 S Kihei Rd, Kihei, HI 96753, United States

Conclusion

Sugar Beach Bake Shop and Ululani’s Hawaiian Shave Ice are two of the top dessert places in Maui. Ice cream, especially flavors like macadamia nut ice cream and coconut ice cream, rank among the island’s best desserts. Don’t forget the banana cream pie, a delight many consider a must-try dessert in Maui. Pie shop lovers can also indulge in coconut cream pie or a savory chicken pot pie.

Best shaved ice in Maui? Head to Ululani’s for their shaved ice topped with natural fruit juice or premium fruit purees. For those seeking local Maui desserts, the lilikoi cheesecake and hula pie are unbeatable.

Want more sweet treats? Look for cream puffs, strawberry cream pie, or the refreshing dole whip.

Ensure you wrap up your Maui dessert tour with a slice of banana bread drizzled with salted caramel and a sprinkle of powdered sugar. There’s no shortage of Maui sweet treats to discover!

FAQs

What desserts are Maui known for?

Maui is known for its variety of desserts that both locals and tourists crave. Some of the desserts that are quite popular in Maui include Hula pie, malasadas, shaved ice, and lilikoi desserts. These unique treats will make your day with soft, crunchy, and tasty flavors. 

Are Maui desserts expensive?

It depends on where you go to eat desserts, as the prices can vary a lot based on the spots. If you buy some desserts from a bakery or cafe, it won’t cost you much, only about $5 to $10. But if you do go to a fancy restaurant, then desserts will probably cost you more than $15. One of the best options for a good affordable dessert is to go to the food trucks in Maui. 

Which places in Maui are best for desserts?

There are tons of places in Maui that have top-quality desserts. Some of the best places that you can go for a good, reasonably priced dessert include Leoda’s Kitchen, Maui Gelato and Waffles, Hula Cookies and Ice Cream, and Ono Gelato Co. You can choose from the variety of desserts in these locations, and the best part is that they don’t cost too much.

Last Updated on August 15, 2023 by Brigitte