Best Bakery in Kauai: Unbelievable Pastries You MUST Try!

Kauai is your destination, and top bakeries are your quest. Welcome, pastry lovers!

In the recent weeks, my partner and I took the liberty of sacrificing our waistlines to explore the local bakeries in Kauai. We dove straight into the warm, tempting embrace of fresh baked goods Kauai style, sampling every tantalizing piece that came our way. It was a feast for the senses!

We approached our Hawaiian getaway with a voracious appetite. We share a fondness for everything rich and sweet – any delight that combines sugar, butter, and flour. Kauai, brimming with unique eateries, was our gastronomical paradise. From sunrise to well beyond sunset, we savored everything – pies, donuts, and croissants – from various Hawaiian bakeries dotting this gorgeous island.

What we have for you now is a curated collection of Kauai’s dessert places that stand out based on their assortment, taste, and ambiance. Our goal is to ensure your dining experiences here remain anything but mundane.

Forewarning: Get your dentist ready for a call! Once you skim through this Hawaii bakery guide, resisting the alluring selection of Kauai sweet treats might be a feat too great. We are two helpless dessert addicts guiding you, after all!

Now, without any more delay, let’s dive into the delicious world of Kauai pastries and all the scrumptious delights this island sweets Kauai paradise has to offer!

#1. The Right Slice LLC, Kalaheo – Best Kauai Bakery

Just thinking about this place makes my mouth water. I never imagined that so many delicious pies could be in one place! This small bakery has the largest selection of pies I have ever seen. The smell of sweet, tangy, fruity, and nutty treats hits you as you walk in. Once you see your choices, it’s hard to leave!

We knew we wanted to make lunch from this visit, so we also got some savory pies. I had the classic chicken pot pie, and my boyfriend had the pork and peas pie. They were both tasty and well-seasoned. The crust was flack; even though the inside was creamy, nothing was soggy.

As far as the sweet pies, I got too many to count! They pack each piece of pie so it’s easy to pick up. We bought some island lime, mango Lilikoi, Belgian chocolate, blueberry pina colada, and tropical banana (they were out of chocolate coconut macaroon!)

Choosing our favorites was impossible, but it didn’t stop us from arguing. In the end, I said the island lime was my favorite. My boyfriend said blueberry pina colada was the best.

Note: They do special orders, so just let them know several days in advance. They have vegetarian and gluten-free options too!

This bakery is a must-stop on your trip because:

• They have an amazing selection of savory and sweet pies.
• Everything is fresh and made in-house from scratch.
• You can buy whole pies or pick and choose piece by piece.
• They do special orders.

Address: 2-2459 Kaumualii Hwy, Kalaheo, HI 96741

#2. Orly Patisserie – Best Birthday Cakes Kauai

This is a close second pick for me! This shop has the perfect combination of sweet and savory products, bread, donuts, and everything else!

We came early, so the shop was fully stocked. There was parking in front of the shopping center. We bought everything we needed for breakfast and snacks for our hike. The smell in this place was like a hug! They run out of food, so plan. The couple behind us got some of everything.

We got some bacon, onion and cheese scones, and Ham and croissants for breakfast. The dough was flakey, chewy, and aromatic. It had a wonderful savory taste. Everything was right out of the oven and buttery.

For sweets and snacks, we got:

• Lemon bars (my favorite).
• Big Chocolate Chip Cookies with Macadamia Nuts.
• Cinnamon buns.
• Blueberry cream cheese Danishes.
• Apple turnovers.

These were the best lemon bars and cookies I have ever had (yes, better than my mom’s!). The other snacks were also very tasty and rich.

I am not a fan of macaroons, but my boyfriend tried two with Lilikoi and honey lavender. He said they were perfect!

I wanted to try the cheesecakes and chocolate cake, but because of our hike, it was impractical.

NOTE: if you pre-order, they do cakes for special occasions!

Not visiting Orly Patisserie would be a shame because:

• They have everything a bakery should have from A to Z (sweet and savory).
• The goods are perfectly baked, impeccably seasoned, and always fresh.
• They have cakes and cheesecake for special occasions.

Address: 4454 Nuhou St #507, Lihue, HI 9676

#3. Aloha Sweet Delights – Best Malasadas in Kauai

I arrived hungry at this bakery early in the morning (left my boyfriend sleeping!) The service was smiling, and the display was full of yummy donuts and pastries. It’s part of a local grocery store, just like my favorite bakery back home.

I bought a lot of food to indulge in. Some of my favorites were the chocolate éclairs, maple glazed donuts, and coconut-filled malasadas. The malasadas were scrumptious, and the filling was super creamy. The maple glaze on the donuts wasn’t overly sweet, and the dough was super fresh.

I also had watermelon tapioca on my way back, which was terrific. (Since nothing was left for my boyfriend to try, I destroyed the evidence!)

My boyfriend’s favorite was the Sweet potato Manju. The dough was fluffy, and the filling sweet and rich. This is something we can’t find at home, so definitely worth a try!

This sweet spot makes pies and cakes to order, and I am sure they are delicious. If you are looking for the best malasadas in Kauai this is definitely one of the best rated ones.

Here’s why this is a great bakery:

• Everything here is made from scratch. It is a local business worth supporting.
• There are many baked options, including savory rolls, croissants, donuts, and traditional baked goods from the region.
• It’s an easy stop to make a meal on the go or picnic. They have drinks too.
• It’s a good place to try out some traditional baked goods made less commercially.

Address: 12550 Kaumualii Hwy, Kaumakani, HI 96747

Also read: Where To Get Malasadas in Maui

#4. Kauai Bakery & Coffee – Best Bakery in Lihue Kauai

This is the iconic local bakery, so all roads lead here if you ask. This is the spot for me if you are craving homemade brownies and cookies. They have delivery, so we got our goods in the hotel and paired them with some fresh juice and coffee. Perfect!

The super chocolaty cake-like brownie was my favorite (I have been missing it since I left). The chocolate chip cookie was a second! I love chewy sweets. I also had a lemon bar that was very natural tasting and had a thin, crumbly crust. (I liked it a lot!) My boyfriend’s favorite was the malasadas with guava filing. The filing didn’t taste artificial, and the dough was fluffy.

We couldn’t eat everything, so we had a snack on the beach later.

Since we didn’t visit the bakery, I’m sure we missed out on some additional gems. We will visit the shop on our next trip. I think they only work till noon on some days.

Visit this local gem because:

• The shop has many traditional options to try out.
• They have a wonderful mix of exotic and familiar flavors.
• Everything is fresh, and the dough smells great.
• They have delivery options.

Address: 3-2600 Kaumualii Hwy STE 1526, Lihue, HI 96766

Related: Best Bakery in Maui

Top Bakeries in Kauai

Bakery Name	Highlights	Specialties	Note	Address
The Right Slice LLC, Kalaheo	Amazing selection of savory and sweet pies, everything made in-house from scratch, option to buy whole pies or by piece, special orders accepted	Classic Chicken Pot Pie, Pork and Peas Pie, Island Lime Pie, Mango Lilikoi Pie, Belgian Chocolate Pie, Blueberry Pina Colada Pie, Tropical Banana Pie	They have vegetarian and gluten-free options.	2-2459 Kaumualii Hwy, Kalaheo, HI 96741
Orly Patisserie	Excellent variety of sweet and savory baked goods, perfectly baked and fresh items, cakes and cheesecakes for special occasions	Bacon, Onion and Cheese Scones, Ham and Croissants, Lemon Bars, Big Chocolate Chip Cookies with Macadamia Nuts, Cinnamon Buns, Blueberry Cream Cheese Danishes, Apple Turnovers	If you pre-order, they do cakes for special occasions.	4454 Nuhou St #507, Lihue, HI 9676
Aloha Sweet Delights	Traditional baked goods, local business, meals on the go or picnic, many baked options	Chocolate Éclairs, Maple Glazed Donuts, Coconut-filled Malasadas, Watermelon Tapioca, Sweet Potato Manju	This sweet spot makes pies and cakes to order.	12550 Kaumualii Hwy, Kaumakani, HI 96747
Kauai Bakery & Coffee	Traditional options, exotic and familiar flavors, fresh items, delivery options	Homemade Brownies, Cookies, Lemon Bars, Malasadas with Guava Filing	Works till noon on some days.	3-2600 Kaumualii Hwy STE 1526, Lihue, HI 96766

9 Must-Try Kauai Food Spots (from a local resident of Hawaii)

Conclusion

Kauai has so much natural beauty to offer that our trip was fantastic. Besides the enthralling sights, Kauai County was truly a foodie’s paradise. Since we did a lot of hiking, we enjoyed and appreciated the wonderful bakeries the area had to offer.

The best part is that we found some amazing desserts and treats along with our expected homemade baked goods. Among the various delicacies, the macadamia nut sticky buns and savory pastries became our favorites. The sticky buns, in particular, were a delightful surprise that left us wanting more.

If someone special is having a birthday or anniversary, get the perfect cake or pie at The Right Slice LLC, Kalaheo, or Orly Patisserie. They all offer a fantastic range of pastries that will definitely impress.

Looking for a quick pick-me-up? Try out the renowned macadamia nut infused coffee at Kauai Bakery & Coffee. The unique flavor of the macadamia nut in the coffee was truly an experience to relish.

Check them all out. They have some of the best goods you will taste.

FAQ

What makes Kauai bakeries stand out from the rest?

Kauai bakeries, like the well-known Kilauea Bakery, offer a unique combination of Hawaiian coffee drinks, french pastries, french toast and other pies that make them stand out from the rest. They have something to satisfy every kind of sweet tooth – from their super delicious cakes to their lilikoi chiffon pie, perfect for a birthday cake Their ice cream is also a local favorite, making them a must-visit for dessert lovers in Kauai, Hawaii.

What kinds of experiences can people expect when visiting a bakery in Kauai?

When visiting a bakery in Kauai, people can expect friendly service and maybe even some long lines due to the popularity of these establishments! But it’s worth it once you get your hands on freshly baked goods like their signature passion fruit glazed cake or fluffy croissants. Additionally, many bakeries also offer coffee shops where one can relax and enjoy their morning cup of joe! These bakeries often have a menu filled with various options for a perfect breakfast or dessert experience.

You might also like: Top Restaurants on Kauai

Why should I choose a bakery in Kauai for my wedding cake?

A bakery in Kauai is an ideal choice for your wedding cake because they not only have top-tier ingredients but they are well known for creating unique designs for any special occasion. From sculpted cakes to multi tiers with intricate icing details, you could trust experienced bakers here to give you your dream wedding cake. Plus, all their items taste as good as they look – giving your guests something memorable yet so tasty!

How do I know if I am getting the best quality cakes at Kauai’s bakeries?

When looking for the best quality cakes at Kauai’s bakeries, keep an eye out for fresh ingredients and locally sourced organic produce that is used in making the cakes and other items. Nothing beats homemade goodness made with love! Additionally look at reviews online or ask locals what bakery they recommend. A good benchmark would be: “If it tastes too good and has rave reviews then it’s certainly one of the best quality cakes around town”.

What makes Kilauea Bakery the best place to go for delicious cake?

Kilauea Bakery, recognized by Hawaii Magazine as one of the top spots for delectable cake in Kauai. They offer a wide selection of super tasty flavors, with each cake being exceptionally fresh and moist. Their professional bakers create delightful masterpieces that look almost too beautiful to eat! Combined with friendly service and reasonable prices, it’s not hard to see why so many people consider Kilauea Bakery their favorite bakery.

How has Kilauea Bakery established itself among Kauai’s best bakeries?

Kilauea Bakery has been around since way back in 1991 and has earned a loyal following over the years. Each pastry is crafted from scratch with high-quality ingredients, making sure customers get an unforgettable experience every time. They also offer an abundance of unique flavors and good selection for those looking for something specific, making it easy to find something you’ll love no matter your taste preferences.

What makes Koloa Town a must-visit destination in the Hawaiian Islands?

Koloa Town is a charming small island town that offers visitors an array of experiences, from exploring old Koloa Town to indulging in the best cake and bakery items. Visitors can also enjoy delicious coffee and breakfast at bakeries in Kauai, while taking advantage of outdoor seating options that are wheelchair accessible.

Where can I find the best shave ice on Garden Island?

If you’re looking for the best shave ice on Garden Island, head over to one of the many local shops in Koloa Town. These shops offer a variety of flavors and toppings that will satisfy any sweet tooth.

Are there any bakeries with outdoor seating options in Kauai?

Yes! There are several bakeries in Kauai that offer outdoor seating options where you can enjoy your coffee or breakfast while taking in the beautiful scenery. Some even have wheelchair-accessible areas so everyone can enjoy their delicious bakery items.

What should I expect when visiting Old Koloa Town?

When visiting Old Koloa Town, expect to be transported back in time with its historic buildings and quaint charm. You’ll also find some of the best cake and bakery items around, as well as great coffee spots perfect for starting your day off right.

Why should I visit small islands like Garden Island during my trip to Hawaii?

Small islands like Garden Island offer visitors a unique experience away from crowded tourist destinations. In addition to enjoying some of the best shave ice around, you’ll get to explore charming towns like old Koloa town and indulge in delicious bakery items at local bakeries. Plus, with plenty of outdoor seating options available (many wheelchair accessible), it’s easy to take advantage of Hawaii’s beautiful weather while enjoying your favorite treats.

Last Updated on July 24, 2023 by Brigitte